• By: Frank Schäfer more
  • To: Covent Garden; Place Charles Rogier/Charles ...
  • Region: Europäische Union more
    Topic: Science mehr
  • Status: Subscription period active
  • 47 days remaining
  • 7 Supporters
    7 in Europäische Union
    0% achieved of
    390.000  for quorum  (?)

Prohibition of Imposing MISRA Compliance in Coding Standards

-

Companies shall no longer be permitted to impose MISRA compliance as a coding standard. Any mentioning of such a requirement in a contract between two entities shall be ineffective.

Reasons:

The original goal of MISRA was to improve code quality by means of static code checking. That is, code is judged without any level of reflection. The fact is, that human written code can hardly be judged without reflection. Furthermore, the overwhelmingly strict standards tend to add a huge amount of visual noise into code that is otherwise safe and sound. Changes done to code due to MISRA tend to introduce new, hard to find errors.

On the other hand, MISRA compliance is often required by the uninformed management league that needs some type of quantifiable data. Requiring MISRA, though, causes a huge amount of extra work to be done with a value add that is at best zero.

Prohibiting the imposition of MISRA helps to avoid the negative impact of this standard on the European Software Industry. Today, there are much more sophisticated means to ensure code quality, such as Unit Tests and tools that reflect on code. There is no need for MISRA.

In the name of all signers.

50169, 20 Jul 2016 (aktiv bis 19 Jan 2017)


News

Fixed typo. Neue Begründung: The original goal of MISRA was to improve code quality by means of static code checking. That is, code is judged without any level of reflection. The fact is, that human written code can hardly be judged without reflection. ...

>>> Go to petition news


Debate about petition

No PRO argument yet.
>>> Be the first to write a PRO argument.

No CONTRA argument yet.
>>> Write the first CONTRA argument


Why supporters sign

:-)

>>> Go to comments


Embed signing form on your own website.


Embed banner in your own website.

Code snippet horizontal:      
Code snippet vertical:           
Code snippet vertical:           

Supporters by country

Landnumber  Quorum?
Deutschland 6 0,0%
Österreich 2 0,0%

Latest signatures

  • Nicht öffentlich Wien | Austria on 12 Nov 2016
  • Mirko C. Wuppertal on 20 Aug 2016
  • Nicht öffentlich Lohmar on 08 Aug 2016
  • Nicht öffentlich Köln on 21 Jul 2016
  • Nicht öffentlich Köln on 20 Jul 2016
  • Jochen B. Neuss on 20 Jul 2016
  • Nicht öffentlich Kerpen on 20 Jul 2016

Petition statistics

Short link